The Subtle Red Flags I Ignored: How I Finally Knew It Was Time to Let Go

The hidden signs: How to know when it’s time to move on (even when you aren’t sure)

Sometimes, it’s not the dramatic moments or screaming matches that tell us when to let go. Sometimes it’s the small, hardly-there red flags that slowly chip away at us, bit by bit. 

For me, the truth didn’t come out all at once. It was a slow burn, until the day my husband looked me in my eyes and said he no longer loved me —  and probably never did.

His words were a punch in the gut, but, even then, I wasn’t sure if it meant we were truly over. I thought somehow, we were still worth the fight. With nine kids and 22 years together, it seemed a lot to simply walk away from.

And there were many reasons to try to make us work — after all, no marriage is perfect. So, even after he’d said those words to me, I stayed another year, trying to piece us back together. 

Perhaps I was stuck in the sunk cost fallacy — I’d invested too much over the years to simply get a divorce. The thought of walking away from everything we’d built kept me holding on, even if the truth was there in front of me. 

But when we’re in the thick of it, the lines are a bit more blurred. How do we know if we’re holding on out of fear, or because there’s something left worth fighting for? 

What I didn’t know then was I’d slowly, piece by piece, lost myself trying to hold us together. And yet, with the kids depending on us, it felt impossible to walk away.

I wasn’t just fighting for my marriage — I was fighting for them. But eventually, I had to ask myself: Was staying really what was best for them — or for me?

“The only thing more unthinkable than leaving was staying; the only thing more impossible than staying was leaving.” — Elizabeth Gilbert

The red flags weren’t just in his words. They were in the way he looked at me — or didn’t. The dismissive comments that cut a little deeper each time. The constant pull to escape, to be anywhere but home. And in the growing distance between us that spoke louder than words. 

I noticed these subtle, quiet, almost unnoticeable shifts, of course, but they were easy to dismiss. Maybe on some level it was self-sabotage — convincing myself if I ignored the signs, I wouldn’t have to face the truth. He’d already left; I just wasn’t ready to see it.

I Thought I Understood

You know that moment when everything suddenly makes sense? When all the puzzle pieces finally fit, after years of trying to force them together? 

The red flags had been there all along, and deep down, I’d known. That subtle gut-level feeling that something just wasn’t right had been with me for quite some time. But acknowledging them meant admitting I’d been holding together a lie.

Signs. Signs. And More Signs.

The way he’d scroll through his phone when I spoke, or sit a little further from me on the couch when we watched a movie. Dinners were more silence than words. The family photo he used as his screensaver disappeared. 

When he walked by me, he no longer reached out to touch me like he always used to. 

We used to go on business trips with him — he never liked being away from us. He’d always say that the room felt too empty without us there. Now, he spoke fondly about the time away, like it was something he craved — something he needed.

It was like I’d faded into the background, and became his afterthought.

Alone, these things didn’t mean much. But together they painted a much different picture, one I wasn’t ready to see.

It’s funny how easy it is to explain away all the little things, to believe they don’t matter, until suddenly, they do. 

I found ways to brush off the signs, convincing myself: Maybe I’m just too insecure. Maybe I’m being unreasonable. Maybe it’s normal for a man to openly ogle the nurses in the hospital — while I’m in labor (I know, right?). 

Maybe, maybe, maybe. Until my maybes stacked up so high, they became impossible to ignore.

Seeing What I Didn’t Want to See

You see it wasn’t like I didn’t know something was off. I did. I’d read about Gottman’s Four Horsemen years before — Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness, and Stonewalling—warning signs that often predict the end of a relationship, back when things were still good.

I had tucked it away in my mind, thinking it didn’t apply to us — believing it never would. I remember checking them off in my mind, reassured: “Well, at least we don’t have that problem.”

But when the signs began showing up, I wasn’t ready to face it. Knowing and doing are two different things. Acknowledging the truth meant confronting the impossible. Leaving meant uprooting my kids, admitting I failed, and giving up on the life we knew.

I convinced myself if I tried a little harder, showed more patience, and put my needs aside a little longer, we’d find our way back.

Line in the sand 

But hope built on maybes is a fragile thing. And at some point, all the maybes stop us from living the life we deserve. It’s like building a brick wall around our happiness.

I was a firm believer in making the marriage work at all costs, aside from my line in the sand — adultery. As long as that wasn’t crossed, I convinced myself I could handle the rest.

The irony? That last year, I knew deep down. I was holding on, but it wasn’t love that anchored me anymore. It was the weight of the years, the life we’d built, our family. But I’d already started drifting, even if I wasn’t ready to see it.

When Hiding Behind “Maybes” No Longer Works

I thought I needed a grand, dramatic betrayal to justify throwing in the towel. Even when he told me he didn’t love me anymore, a part of me believed it could’ve been a midlife crisis — something we could work through.

I thought I could still save us, but it came at my expense. I kept shrinking myself to fit into a relationship that no longer had room for me. The more I tried to hold on, the more I felt myself disappearing.

One day, writing in my journal, I could barely recognize who I was. 

Over that last year, I realized he didn’t need to cross my line for me to leave. Standing by my man didn’t apply when it meant losing myself. Even without crossing my line, our relationship had already drained me of who I was.

So I stopped fighting for us and let go. 

A few months after I filed for divorce, the truth came out. Even though he swore up and down it wasn’t true, he’d been having an affair during the time he told me he never loved me. That entire last year was built on nothing but lies and deceit.

---

You Might Also Like:

The Secret He Kept from Me (and Our 9 Children) for a Year
When a 22-year marriage becomes a sham

---

It hurt, of course. But in the end, it also affirmed what I’d already known. I deserved better.

I didn’t leave because he was unfaithful, I left because I knew I was worth more than what I’d been settling for. And thatis empowering on all levels.

Every Relationship Has Its Own Story

Listening to our inner voice is part science, part art. What we see logically doesn’t always fit with what we feel emotionally. My heart was afraid to admit we’d crossed a line we couldn’t uncross.

Understanding and acceptance are worlds apart, and it took me far too long to see the difference. The red flags were there, and though I could understand them, accepting them was a whole other thing. 

But red flags are there for a reason. Sometimes they’re whispers of something needing attention or that something is deeply wrong. Ignoring them doesn’t make them go away, it only prolongs the choice of whether to work through it or move on.

Looking back, I think the hardest part wasn’t seeing the signs — it was accepting I’d seen them all along but wasn’t able to face what they meant.

But every relationship has its own story. No two are alike, and sometimes the bravest thing we can do is to trust ourselves — to know when it’s time to hold on or let go.

In the end, it wasn’t just about his words or the red flags — it was about how I chose to value myself, even when walking away felt impossible.

“Sometimes it takes a heartbreak to shake us awake & help us see we are worth so much more than we’re settling for.” — Mandy Hale